Hmmm.. the frequency response of those headphones may have been more
accurate than the monitors, but unless the resulting material is
intended for playback on headphones only I don't understand why the
engineer is leaping at the chance to use these ultra-common AKG
phones?
Back in the mid 70-80's they were not that common sounding compared to
many others on the market. I think back now, and I believe it was
Grado, that made a light weight set that I was pleased with also.
This is a beginners mistake. An experienced engineer will be
aware of the pitfalls in translation between headphone mix and regular
speaker playback, and will most likely balk at the idea of doing
anything more than using headphones to scrutinize fine detail..
Could be why his rates were cheap and in the range our band could afford
to do a demo tape - lol
Don't remember who the engineer was, not the person I mentioned but some
article in a Guitar Player " magazine, but they would take their final
mix and listen to it in a car's radio back in the 60-70's to see how
they would sound in that environment and make adjustments accordingly.
This backs up exactly what you said about the final end user listening
enviroment that should be the main mixdown concern.
To quote a somewhat pro-headphone orientated article on the subject
(worth reading for background, but not wholly representative) at
Headwise "Headphone mixes can sound terrible when played back over
loudspeakers, due to the different characteristics of the soundfields
such as frequency response, interchannel crosstalk and
spatialization."
I have to agree that a lot of music today seems to be mixed more for the
"walkman" use than the home system use. Some of the details that show
up in headphones are for the most part impossible to hear through
average home speakers.
I did not delete the below link in case some one missed it in an earlier
thread. It is some good reading!
http://headwize2.powerpill.org/articles/mixing_art.htm
Which listening environment do you think a band should use for demos
now. Back then, the cassette demo was the easiest to use because CD had
not come into play because of $$$ to the bands.
Thanks for your thoughts and comments!
John