"TT" wrote in message
...

snipped for readability purposes


How do you know Phil's medical condition?

It has been openly discussed on and off groups

Oh well, that's *real* evidence! (not :-()

and MDs have offered their opinion.

Then they shouldn't have done, that is a clear breach of medical ethics. In
any case unless they have treated him themselves their opinion counts for
little.


My dislike of your pal

When did Rob ever describe Phil as his "pal"? It seems to be a habit of
yours to claim that other people are "defending" someone when all they are
doing is objecting to your way of making ill-informed judgements about other
people.

I kill-filed Phil a long time ago because, although he has much to
contribute, I am not prepared to correspond with anyone who's response to
any post that contradicts his views is to launch into a barrage of foul
language. That's all I need to do, and if everyone did that he would
effectively cease to exist as far as Usenet is concerned. Producing
web-sites devoted to him, along with quack "diagnosis" of his medical
condition is IMHO utterly inappropriate.

David.