View Single Post
  #2 (permalink)  
Old February 16th 15, 12:27 AM posted to uk.rec.audio
Trevor Wilson
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 801
Default P-Mount bd and dd

On 15/02/2015 9:49 PM, Sumatriptan wrote:
Firstly,

Thank you all for the advice/suggestions in the Vinyl to digital thread.
All carefully noted.

I'm currently looking on ebay at turntables, getting a feel for the
market. Here's 2 questions:

1) Sellers seem a bit coy on cartridge types and I'm assuming that I
could be looking at cartridge/stylus replacement if I purchase a tt. (I
couldn't find my beloved M75 in the loft)

Should I avoid tts that use P-mount carts? The impression I get is that
they were designed as lower end items and I've read that there doesn't
seem much choice among 'audiophile quality' P-mount carts.


**Depends on a number of factors. Including:

* Choice is future cartridge types is somewhat restricted.
* Tone arms which accept P-Mount cartridges TEND to be less good than
standard mount types.
* Your future requirements.

P-Mount cartridges and arms are satisfactory, without being outstanding
(though there are a tiny handful of exceptions).


2) Direct drive. They seem to be fetching rather higher prices than belt
drive types. Again, I've read some of the pros/cons regarding belt wear
and dd motor noise.


**A really good belt drive can offer performance equal to a really good
DD. OTOH, there are possibly more important factors to be considered.
These include:

* Suspension systems.
* Tone arm quality.

A really good DD will likely cost more than a roughly equivalent belt
drive. Motor noise, with a really good DD (like, say a high end Denon or
Technics) is not going to be a problem, assuming the bearings are in
good condition. Same deal with a belt drive. A bearing in poor condition
will contribute noise to the system.


Your opinions please?


**If you can locate one, a Denon DP59L (DD) will provide excellent
performance, with a range of cartridges, for a couple of centuries. A
Rega is hard to beat, for the money, with new turntables. All manual and
belt drive, but the tone arm is excellent.

--
Trevor Wilson
www.rageaudio.com.au

---
This email has been checked for viruses by Avast antivirus software.
http://www.avast.com