max graff wrote:
Seriously, MP3 is a sacrilage to sound quality at least for old timers
like me who have grown up on vinyl and recently embrassed CD audio.
Actually MP3 can sound pretty good, *if*...
You use a decent encoder (eg LAME).
You keep the bitrate high enough, over 192Kbit or better still VBR.
You use j-stereo wherever possible (avoids ringing artefacts in the
surround channels if you squirt it through a Pro-Logic decoder).
You use decent hardware to play it back on.
I personally encode using LAME with options "-mj -b32 -V0 -q1". You're
hard pushed to tell the difference even in a back-to-back comparison.
As for the hardware... most PC sound cards are appalling. But an MP3
played on my iPod through the dock will sound better than the same track
played from the original CD from my old Technics player (SL-PG590).
Burn a CD-R full of MP3s and lob it in the DVD player (Arcam DV-79) and
you'll be hard pushed to tell the difference.
Or use something like a Slim Squeezebox, Turtle Beach Audiotron etc with
the digital output going straight into the AV receiver (Arcam AVR-250)
and again you'll be hard pushed to tell the difference.
--
Glenn Richards Tel: (01453) 845735
Squirrel Solutions
http://www.squirrelsolutions.co.uk/
IT consultancy, hardware and software support, broadband installation