Don Pearce wrote:
On Sun, 10 Jan 2010 18:30:55 +1300, Mike Coatham
wrote:

Jim Lesurf wrote:
Hi,

I've just put up a new web page at

http://www.audiomisc.co.uk/HFN/Squar...quareDeal.html

that looks at the use of squarewaves for assessing amplifiers, etc.

During a tidy up I found a 6 page article on "Square Wave Testing of Audio
Amplifiers" in the NZ publication - Radio & Electrical Review - of August
1955. In it, it goes on to describe the testing of amplifiers using square
waves as a relatively new process.

And just to show that that the more things change the more they stay the
same, the article also says - and I quote "Now when we have a number of
amplifiers whose specifications, as outlined , indicate such excellent
performance, one might legitimately expect, when listening tests are
conducted, using identical programme material, and the same pick-up and
speaker system, that all the amplifiers sound the same. It was with
considerable surprise that we found exactly the opposite. "

They did tests on 7 un-named amplifiers and included oscillograms of the
amplifiers at 30hz, 400hz & 10,000hz.

The conclusion reached was that square wave testing "can help sort the
sheep from the goats. With all its advantages, this type of test will still
not give an unambiguous answer to the 40 dollar question ...Will this
amplifier sound well on music?. It will give the experienced worker a
pretty good idea of where his designs could be improved, and it seems that
the very best amplifiers do give very similar square wave results. Where
faults are apparent, the test shows them up much more clearly than any
other method, and will also indicate fault conditions that cannot readily
be discovered at all in any other way."

So here we are, 55 years down the track and its deja vu all over again :0

Mike


No chance of scanning it and making it available, is there? That would
be interesting.

d

No problem with that - I'll send you a copy later today. I'd also send Jim
a copy too before he gets on my case

Don Pearce wrote:
On Sun, 10 Jan 2010 18:30:55 +1300, Mike Coatham
wrote:

Jim Lesurf wrote:
Hi,

I've just put up a new web page at

http://www.audiomisc.co.uk/HFN/Squar...quareDeal.html

that looks at the use of squarewaves for assessing amplifiers, etc.

During a tidy up I found a 6 page article on "Square Wave Testing of Audio
Amplifiers" in the NZ publication - Radio & Electrical Review - of August
1955. In it, it goes on to describe the testing of amplifiers using square
waves as a relatively new process.

And just to show that that the more things change the more they stay the
same, the article also says - and I quote "Now when we have a number of
amplifiers whose specifications, as outlined , indicate such excellent
performance, one might legitimately expect, when listening tests are
conducted, using identical programme material, and the same pick-up and
speaker system, that all the amplifiers sound the same. It was with
considerable surprise that we found exactly the opposite. "

They did tests on 7 un-named amplifiers and included oscillograms of the
amplifiers at 30hz, 400hz & 10,000hz.

The conclusion reached was that square wave testing "can help sort the
sheep from the goats. With all its advantages, this type of test will still
not give an unambiguous answer to the 40 dollar question ...Will this
amplifier sound well on music?. It will give the experienced worker a
pretty good idea of where his designs could be improved, and it seems that
the very best amplifiers do give very similar square wave results. Where
faults are apparent, the test shows them up much more clearly than any
other method, and will also indicate fault conditions that cannot readily
be discovered at all in any other way."

So here we are, 55 years down the track and its deja vu all over again :0

Mike


No chance of scanning it and making it available, is there? That would
be interesting.

d
Don can you e-mail me direct and I'll send you the pdf My first attempt to
get it to you got bounced.

Mike

"Mike Coatham" wrote

During a tidy up I found a 6 page article on "Square Wave Testing of Audio
Amplifiers" in the NZ publication - Radio & Electrical Review - of August
1955. In it, it goes on to describe the testing of amplifiers using square
waves as a relatively new process.


In an advertising pamphlet from Haynes Radio that I have; undated but
probably from the late 1940s, there is the following sentence at the end of
the description of their "Quality Amplifier":-

quote
Amplifier designs are developed with the aid of a square wave-form
generator, which experience has shown will reveal defects unobserved by
tests with oscillator and distortion factor meter, and upon which quite
misleading test data might be based.
unquote

Incidentally this Amplifier (£18.10s plus £6.15s for the PSU) uses 4
triodes, including a pair of PX4s in the output stage.

David.