In article , Dave Plowman (News)
wrote:
In article , Jim Lesurf
wrote:
I'd love to be able compare with R3 on Freeview again. But up here in
t'frozen North the BBC have removed R3 from DVB-T in the evenings!
Fortunately, the 320k iPlayer stream is excellent.
What 'gem' are you offered in its place?
BBC Alba TV. i.e. a Gaelic station. One minority group TV station replacing
the bulk of the BBC's UK radio output.
This happened as a result of a 'political lobby' who want to promote Gaelic
under the banner that this is essentially a synonym with 'Scots' - which it
isn't. Most Scots speak, erm, 'Scottish' / English of various forms and
have little or no interest in Gaelic. Indeed the people I've known who are
keen Scots Nats regard Gaelic as about as relevant to modern Scotland as
Shortbread Tins and Kilts. Fine simply for easing money out of the wallets
of tourists... :-)
The BBC Trust did run a 'consultation exercise'. But there was almost no
publicity directed at those who actually listen to the BBC Radio stations
in Scotland. So - unless you were politically plugged in to the Gaelic
lobby - you would not have known. Most people didn't even know the decision
was taken.
The result was a curiously 'biassed' (in statistical terms) set of
responses. Over 40 percent of responses were from Gaelic speakers and
people seriously interested in Gaelic. ahem The figure for the general
Scots population for that is about 2 percent depending on how you define
the terms. So 20-fold over-representation. And the consultation questions
gave no real way to say "I'd like Alba Gaelic TV but *not* by sacrificing
all the normal radio." It was in essence, "That's the deal."
They also slid in the change as part of the DSO. So I suspect many people
don't even know *why* they can't now get the radio on DVB-T after the late
afternoons.
I fairly recently wanted to watch BBC1 Scotland - a play which was only
on that. So via satellite. I'd guess you could always find R3 via that
too.
Yes, you can get BBC 'sound radio' in various ways. I find the iPlayer most
convenient and the 320k aac+ R3 stream sounds excellent to me. The problem
is that some people can't get satellite or a decent net stream. And these
methods tend to require additional cost for people who just have a
terrestrial TV.
Slainte,
Jim
--
Please use the address on the audiomisc page if you wish to email me.
Electronics
http://www.st-and.ac.uk/~www_pa/Scot...o/electron.htm
Armstrong Audio
http://www.audiomisc.co.uk/Armstrong/armstrong.html
Audio Misc
http://www.audiomisc.co.uk/index.html